Profile Picture
Truth and Justice don’t always agree. We’re here to bring attention to the cases where the American Criminal Justice system got it wrong.

S02E09 – Day 4 Part 2 – Vincent Cosey Case

This season’s case involves a black man in a racist village called Caledonia, in Racine County, Wisconsin. Home state of the Steven Avery case (Making a Murderer) and the Kyle Rittenhouse case, Wisconsin seems to be very controversial in the way it hands down … justice. This episode covers the second part of Day 4 of the trial.

A big shout out to Nic from the True Crime Garage for submitting the Vincent Cosey case. You’ll hear from Nic throughout the season. We hope you enjoy!

0:00 Previously on the American Justice Podcast

01:24 Introduction

02:19 Episode Begins

06:12 Nic & Scott Discuss No Recordings Being Made

10:16 Resume Episode

14:47 Nic & Scott Discuss Even Police Have Bad Apples Too

19:08 Resume Episode

37:30 Vinnie Discusses Stefnee’s Friends and Why He Didn’t Hang Around Them

40:52 Resume Episode

41:42 Nic & Scott Discuss the Different Types of Innocence

50:58 Resume Episode

51:28 Nic & Scott – Thank You’s & Goodbyes

54:16 Wrap Up

YouTube Channel:

Where to Listen:

Apple –

Stitcher –

Spotify –

Online –

If you would like to get in touch with us, you can do so in any of the following ways:


Voicemail: (972) 942-0444

You can reach the hosts here –

Scott Poggensee
Email –

C. Derick Miller

S02E09 – Day 4 Part 2 – Vincent Cosey Case