Profile Picture
Truth and Justice don’t always agree. We’re here to bring attention to the cases where the American Criminal Justice system got it wrong.

S03E03 – Central Park 5

On Season 3, Episode 3 of the American Justice Podcast, Scott and C. Derick tell the story of the Central Park 5 and how it became one of New York’s most notorious racially charged cases. Stay tuned to find out what happened throughout the trials and what happens to the five men charged for a crime they didn’t commit.

Time Stamps

00:04:50          Introducing the Central Park 5 Case

00:15:10          What Happened Trisha Meili in Central Park

00:21:46          Arrest Frenzy and Racial Profiling

00:31:12          Trump’s Calling for the Return of the Death Penalty and Inconclusive Data

00:35:56          Start of the Trials

00:42:02          Trisha Meili on Oprah and Matias Reyes’ Confession

00:52:04          The Central Park 5 v. The City of New York

00:58:51          Where is the Central Park 5 Now?

01:06:41          Final Thoughts

YouTube Channel:

Where to Listen:

Apple –

Stitcher –

Spotify –

Online –

If you would like to get in touch with us, you can do so in any of the following ways:


Voicemail: (972) 942-0444

You can reach the hosts here –

Scott Poggensee
Email –

C. Derick Miller

S03E03 – Central Park 5